On the morning of April 2, the Metcalf brothers were at David Kuykendall Stadium in Frisco, where Austin was preparing to compete in shot-put and discus. The boys were sitting in their school’s designated tent area when an unexpected confrontation began with another student from Centennial High School, later identified as Anthony Karmel.
Hunter explained that the student was sitting under their team’s tent, and when asked to move, the situation escalated rapidly. “He started getting aggressive and talking reckless,” Hunter recalled, “and my brother stepped in and said, ‘you need to move.’ And he’s like, ‘Make me move.’”
A witness said the student responded with, “Touch me and see what happens,” before allegedly pulling a black knife from his backpack and stabbing Austin in the chest. As the attacker fled the scene, Hunter rushed to his brother’s side.
“I put my hand on there, tried to make it [the bleeding] stop, and I grabbed his head and I looked in his eyes,” Hunter said, his voice trembling. “I just saw his soul leave, and it took my soul, too.”
Paramedics arrived and rushed Austin to the hospital, but despite emergency efforts, he could not be saved. He died with his twin brother by his side.
Meghan Metcalf said the pain is unlike anything she’s ever known. “My son is gone, and I don’t really have words,” she shared on The Will Cain Show. “He’s just going to be so missed by mostly our family, but this whole community has really wrapped their arms around us.”
She spoke directly to other parents, urging them to treasure every moment. “Hug your babies tight,” she said. “You don’t know when [is] the last time you get to do it.”
Austin wasn’t just a star athlete — he was a leader, a friend, and a young man with big dreams. College scouts had taken notice of his talent and work ethic. He was described as someone who lifted others up, both on and off the field. His days were filled with early morning workouts, school commitments, and helping his teammates thrive.
The tragedy is made even more painful by the inseparable connection he shared with Hunter. “We were always basically one person,” Hunter said. “He was a big brother even though we’re the same age.”
In the wake of Austin’s death, the alleged attacker, 17-year-old Anthony Karmel, was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. Authorities reported that after the stabbing, Karmel allegedly admitted to it and claimed self-defense. His bond has been set at $1 million.
As the legal process begins, the emotional weight for the Metcalf family remains overwhelming. “I am so angry at that boy,” Meghan admitted. “It’s just not fair.”
Last week, hundreds gathered at the Metcalfs’ church to mourn and celebrate Austin’s life. His teammates, friends, teachers, and complete strangers offered support, creating memorials, tributes, and flooding social media with messages of love and remembrance. Many have called for increased safety measures at school athletic events, hoping to prevent another tragedy like this.
Through it all, Hunter, despite his grief, expressed a depth of empathy rare for someone his age. “I just pray for [the suspect’s] family,” he said. “I pray that they understand what we’re going through as well.”
Austin Metcalf’s story is not just one of loss — it’s a reminder of how fragile life can be, how one violent act can unravel futures, and how the human spirit, even in its darkest hour, can still shine with love, resilience, and grace.
